ESSAY

An Explanation Cannot Take the Author's Place

Víctor Silva

I can recount an argument in a way that makes my reactions understandable. I can connect it to other situations, find words for what affected me, piece together why I believe something carried so much weight. The story may come together well. I may recognize things in it that I hadn’t been able to put into words before, and feel that I now understand what happened better. But when I find myself in a similar situation again, all that knowledge may be available to me, and still something gets the better of me. I’m responding before I’ve finished listening, preparing my defense while the other person speaks, trying to steer the conversation where I need it to go. I can say a great deal about what happens to me. That doesn’t mean I’m there as it’s happening.

There doesn’t even have to be any distance between the argument and the explanation. I can be explaining my reaction while I’m still caught up in it. I can describe quite precisely what bothers me, connect it to my history, recognize something familiar in what is happening, and still be swept along by it. Words don’t necessarily interrupt that absence. They can accompany it. I can say, “I know I’m reacting,” and remain entirely occupied with defending myself, as though naming it had already placed me somewhere different. My voice can speak of understanding while the rest of the conversation remains a fight I need to win. What I say about myself and where I’m coming from when I say it don’t necessarily match.

When I speak of being there, I’m not talking about monitoring myself, either. Being present in a conversation doesn’t mean keeping track of every gesture, examining every sensation, and constantly checking whether I’m present. Watching a sunset, I don’t need to count the clouds to be there. I can simply take it in without describing everything that’s happening. Something similar happens when I drive. I don’t need to think, “Accelerate, brake, change lanes,” to be there for the journey. Much of that is already second nature to me, and that is precisely why I can be there. It’s another thing entirely to drive while caught up in an argument that isn’t actually happening, anticipating a meeting, mentally sorting out my children’s lives, arguing with politics, or trying to solve a problem that isn’t even in front of me at that moment. My body arrives at work. I was barely there for the journey.

Thinking isn’t the problem. I can be thinking. I can remember, plan, imagine, or analyze something and be completely there. Something different happens when my thoughts carry me away in the same way an emotion or a reaction can. I’m not really there with what I’m thinking about or with what’s happening around me. Something keeps functioning. Life goes on and, in a way, it is living me.

Nor do I turn that absence into a failing. I don’t believe I should always be present. I don’t need to make presence another self-improvement project. If I wasn’t there, I wasn’t there. I may realize it an hour later, halfway through a conversation, or once I’ve reached my destination. What matters to me is recognizing that there is a difference between being there and not being there, not using that difference to construct a new morality about how life ought to be lived.

I also know moments when something becomes visible without ever turning into a sentence. I don’t find a cause or identify some scene from my life that explains it. Sometimes I can’t even properly name what I’m recognizing. The anger may still be there, what I heard may still hurt, the urge to respond in a certain way may still be strong, but my relationship with it changes. I can see it while it’s happening. Sometimes it still gets the better of me; other times a moment comes when it no longer does. It’s still there, but it has lost some of its power over me.

I don’t need it to disappear to recognize that difference. Nor do I have to do the opposite of what I would have done before to prove that something has changed. I can leave a conversation because something got the better of me, and I can leave because, being there, I decide not to continue. From the outside, both departures may look identical. To me, they aren’t. I don’t have to stay to prove I’ve become aware of something, or calm myself down to certify that I’m present. The outward form of an action doesn’t necessarily reveal the place it comes from.

I enjoy reflecting on what I discover. Often, realizing something makes me want to keep looking for a while, find other connections, question what first came to mind. There’s pleasure in that discovery. Thinking isn’t outside my life, nor is it necessarily a way of abandoning it. What I don’t need is to turn reflection into an obligatory search for origins, as though I had to find some earlier missing piece before I could face what is happening. I can recognize something without knowing where it comes from. It may take on another meaning later, I may find different words for it, or some new experience may change what I understand today. None of that has to be resolved for this moment to be lived.

Words have a real place in all this. They allow me to return to something I’ve experienced, connect it with other experiences, and find distinctions I hadn’t been able to make before. Sometimes, while trying to express something, a clarity appears that I didn’t have when I began. Other times I find a phrase and recognize in it something I was already seeing but didn’t yet know how to communicate. Speaking isn’t always a matter of putting an already complete understanding into words. I can also discover something while speaking, hear what I’ve just said and realize that it isn’t quite right, that I’ve given too much weight to one part or left something important out.

After a conversation, I might say, “I felt powerless.” Now I have a word I can use to revisit what happened. I can try to clarify what I mean by powerlessness, recognize something familiar in it, share it with the other person. But what I experienced wasn’t made up solely of what that word manages to name. There was a way of listening, of receiving what was being said, of wanting to be understood, of being with that person at that moment. All of it was happening together. Even when the word seems right, something remains outside it. I don’t always feel that I’ve chosen the wrong word. Sometimes I feel that no choice of words could contain the richness of what happened.

The same thing happens when I try to explain what I experience with certain music. I can talk about what moves me, recognize particular moments, find associations, and say things that matter to me. But the explanation makes no sound. I can become extremely precise and still fail to convey what happens when I listen. I find something similar when I try to explain love. Words can bring me closer to another person, open a conversation, make visible something we hadn’t said before. All of that has value in itself. But it isn’t the same as loving. Some experiences are so rich, made up of so many things happening at once, that when I try to bring them into rational terms, something seems to die.

That doesn’t mean putting things into words only takes something away. Something new also happens when I speak. I can hear myself differently, discover a connection, encounter another person through what I’m trying to communicate. A conversation about an experience can have a richness of its own, something that didn’t exist before that conversation. But it isn’t the earlier experience preserved intact. It’s happening now, from where I am now. If I return to something years later, I’m not simply recovering what it meant back then. I’m also looking at it from everything that has happened since. It may take on a different tone. It may no longer occupy the place it once did. Words take part in that movement; they don’t speak from somewhere outside it.

Nor do I carry my past only as a film I can recount. I keep scenes, stories that make me laugh or feel nostalgic, memories that help me recognize where I’ve been. But when I speak of what I carry from my past, I’m pointing to something that doesn’t depend on reconstructing that film. What I’ve lived takes part in how I receive what happens, in what feels familiar, in what I’m able to notice, even when I don’t remember where it comes from and even when I’ve never managed to express it.

Sometimes something in the present connects with something familiar. I don’t need to claim it’s exactly the same thing or search for the first scene in which it appeared. I recognize a familiarity. That may lead me to look further, remember, reflect, or simply stay there. What I carry from my past doesn’t begin to exist when I find the words to describe it. Nor does it remain static. A new experience can give something I’ve carried for years a different meaning. Not because I’ve finally discovered what it “really” meant, but because the place from which I now receive it has changed too.

That’s why I don’t go looking behind every experience for a phrase that will reveal what was really happening. I don’t feel that whatever I still can’t put into words is waiting for its correct name before it can be understood. I can say “fear of abandonment,” and perhaps that expression will help me think about something. But I may also have placed a familiar category over something far more complex than it can hold. An emotion, a reaction, a sensitivity, a history, the body, the relationship I’m in now, things I can’t even name may all be happening together. Calling it “fear of abandonment” may be useful. It may also give me the illusion that I already know what it is.

The search for an explanation can then become a trap in itself. Not because explaining is bad, but because I may assume that behind something complex there is one true sentence waiting to be discovered. As though understanding meant finding it. Perhaps there is no hidden sentence. Perhaps there is an experience that can be looked at in different ways, some of which help me think more clearly than others without ever containing it completely.

I can continue using a formulation that serves me for years. I don’t need to discard it to prove that I’m still open. I can recognize something and say, “I know this,” and that recognition may be precisely what helps me look more closely. What matters is not confusing the recognition of something with knowing everything that’s happening. What I already know is part of a situation that is still unfolding. It may confirm an earlier interpretation, change it, or show me that something else is happening this time. I don’t have to give up what I carry from my past to receive something new. What I don’t want is for it to arrive with the authority to decide in advance what I’m experiencing.

The difficulty begins when a formulation is no longer something I can examine and instead becomes the lens through which everything must be understood. Reflecting on a situation, I might once have said, “I had a hard time letting someone help me.” Later, that sentence may become “I find it hard to accept help,” and eventually settle into something much more fixed: “I’ve always handled things on my own.” None of those statements has to be false. They may describe an important part of my life. The difference appears when I stop using them to think and start asking them to tell me who I am.

Then something strange happens. What began as an explanation of an experience starts demanding continuity. If I want support today, I’m no longer simply facing my desire to receive it. There’s also an idea of myself that could be called into question if I do. The explanation no longer simply describes how I’ve been; it starts telling me how I’m supposed to go on being.

Someone may tell me that I didn’t listen to them, and I may immediately begin proving that I’m someone who listens. I can recall previous conversations, offer examples of how willing I’ve been to listen, explain how much understanding others matters to me. Perhaps all of that is true. But the person is trying to talk about what happened a moment ago, and I’m responding with a story about myself. The conversation then begins revolving around something else: defending an image of myself that I feel is being questioned. What just happened becomes secondary to my need for it not to mean something incompatible with who I believe I am.

That image doesn’t have to be built on lies. I may have listened many times, supported others, been available when someone needed me. The difficulty appears when that whole history stops being something I can recognize and becomes an identity I have to preserve. It’s no longer enough for listening to have played an important part in my life. Now I need this particular situation to confirm that I’m someone who listens. Admitting that this time I didn’t may feel like losing far more than an argument.

That’s where an explanation can offer me continuity. I can say I was tired, that I was interrupted, that the other person didn’t express themselves well, or that something they said touched a sensitive part of my history. Some of those things may be true and may help me understand what happened. But I can also use them to make sure that nothing about what happened challenges the image I’m defending. Every detail finds a way to fit, and the image remains intact. I don’t even have to deny that I failed to listen. I can admit it and explain it in such a way that it loses its power to show me something new.

The character I construct can also be built from what I dislike about myself. “I don’t know how to receive love.” “People always abandon me.” “I need to be in control.” An explanation that once helped me recognize something can begin to make me feel fully explained. Whatever confirms the image slips easily into place; whatever contradicts it requires another explanation so the image doesn’t have to change. I can hold on to a painful image of myself just as fiercely as I would defend an admirable one. What matters isn’t whether the character makes me look good. It’s whether it ends up becoming the place from which I understand my life.

I don’t even have to repeat those sentences consciously. I may be defending an idea of strength without ever thinking, “I have to be strong.” It may appear in what I consider acceptable, in what I don’t want to show, in what makes me uncomfortable to receive. That’s why asking myself where I’m coming from in the way I’m living isn’t about finding another definition. Sometimes what I manage to see is simpler and more uncomfortable: I’m making an effort to keep this from changing an idea of myself. I don’t have to know when that began to recognize that I’m defending it now.

When I speak of a character, I’m not imagining someone else inside me acting while I remain untouched. I’m the one who argues, falls silent, shuts down, or tries to hold on to a position. Calling it a character helps me look at the image I’m sustaining; it doesn’t allow me to attribute my part in what happened to someone else. I could even turn that word into another convenient explanation: “It was my character.” “It was my ego.” “My wound was triggered.” And I would have found a more sophisticated way of telling the story without facing what I did.

This can happen even with the ideas that matter most to me. I can construct the character of someone who observes himself, who takes responsibility, or who seeks freedom. Then discovering that I wasn’t there, that something got the better of me, or that I’m holding on to a convenient explanation threatens an image that seemed to have been built precisely to avoid those confusions. I can become especially skilled at justifying myself in the language of awareness. Even the way I speak about change and movement can become something I feel compelled to protect against what I’m seeing.

I don’t expect to find a true self beneath those constructions that I can finally give a name to. If, after recognizing an identification, I concluded, “Now I finally know who I am,” I would have repeated the same operation with a different answer. What I can discover is that I’m taking part in defending an idea of myself. That defense may be happening right now. Seeing it doesn’t make the story behind it disappear, nor does it make everything I’ve lived through that way false. What changes is that I no longer need to grant it the right to decide in advance how I must continue.

Nor does discovering a character mean I have to abandon it. I can be with other people talking about something I wouldn’t choose as a subject on my own. Taking part, following the tone of the conversation, telling a story, adjusting the way I express myself. I can notice that I’m playing a particular version of myself and enjoy it. What interests me at that moment may not be the subject we’re discussing, but being with those people. I don’t need to interrupt the gathering to announce that the subject doesn’t particularly interest me, as though doing so were a test of honesty. I can want to share, be liked, belong. Recognizing that desire doesn’t oblige me to dismantle it.

I don’t present myself in the same way everywhere, nor do I need to say everything I think in every conversation. I can understand the ways of a particular setting and take part in them without feeling that I’m giving myself up. Sometimes I make room for someone else’s interest, something I wouldn’t have sought out on my own. If I treated every adjustment as a loss of authorship over my own choices, I’d end up defending a rather rigid image of independence. I’d have to make sure that nothing I did was too heavily influenced by anyone else. But I don’t live outside relationships. Meeting another person also changes what interests me, what I’m able to see, and the ways in which I want to participate.

I can also take a particular form my life has taken seriously and sustain it for a long time. A relationship, a commitment, a profession, a project. There will be moments I wouldn’t choose in isolation and that nevertheless belong to something I still recognize as my own. I don’t have to renegotiate every gesture or ask myself at every moment whether I still want to be there. A form can last decades without becoming a prison. The problem isn’t that it remains. It appears when it can no longer move in response to what happens and calls it into question.

My limit is not to betray myself. By that I don’t mean I have to keep behaving according to some true definition of who I am. I can change my mind, give ground, discover a taste I didn’t have before, allow myself to be influenced, or do something I would once have rejected. None of that necessarily means disregarding myself. What I don’t want is to submit in order to keep my place while feeling that I’m violating something in myself. Belonging can matter enormously to me, but I don’t want that desire to become a condition that requires me to give up my own participation. Nor do I want to demand that another person go against themselves so I can preserve the arrangement I want.

Discomfort doesn’t settle that difference. I may feel uncomfortable precisely because someone is questioning an image I’ve been holding on to for a long time. I can look at that and want to stay. I may also recognize that I no longer want to take part in what’s happening and decide to leave. Observing myself doesn’t have to become an obligation to find some reason within me why I should endure any situation. I don’t need to analyze my discomfort until I can make it acceptable. Looking at it may lead me to change how I participate, not necessarily to preserve the situation.

The other person may show me something I wasn’t seeing. I can begin a conversation convinced of my position and end up thinking differently. That doesn’t mean they defeated me or that I’ve given up my place. It may be precisely what happens when I’m open to the encounter. Something doesn’t have to originate exclusively within me for me to recognize it as part of my choice. Sometimes the defense of the character works in the opposite direction: I’ve seen something, but I keep arguing because changing my mind now would make me feel weak, inconsistent, or too easily influenced. I’m protecting an image of independence while preventing myself from receiving something that has already begun to move me.

Something similar happens with belonging. I may have shared a group’s language and positions for years and then discover that there are things in which I no longer recognize myself. That doesn’t make our entire shared history false, nor does it require me to leave immediately. I can talk, disagree, find another way to be there. But I may also begin systematically keeping quiet about what I see and repeating positions I no longer hold because I’m afraid of losing my place. Then phrases appear that can preserve continuity: “These are my people.” “I’ve always believed in this.” “You don’t abandon what you’ve built.” They may express real bonds. The question is whether I’m still recognizing something I choose, or using those words to force myself to keep being who I used to be.

Nor would I be any freer if I demanded that others change so I wouldn’t have to face the difference. I can express what I want, propose another kind of relationship, or say that I won’t continue under certain conditions. But the other person may not want the same thing. I don’t want to override their choice just to spare myself its cost. My limit doesn’t mean that nobody should feel uncomfortable or that my decisions should stop affecting other lives. A refusal or a departure may hurt. That doesn’t make a decision that belongs to me someone else’s, but neither does it give me the right to decide how the other person should receive it.

I don’t always know clearly what’s happening. I may want to stay and still feel that something is weighing on me. I may suspect that I’m defending an image and, at the same time, genuinely not want what is being proposed. I don’t have to decide immediately which of those things is the true one. I can remain in that mixture. Reflect. Let the encounter continue showing me something. Not knowing what to do doesn’t necessarily mean I’m absent.

That’s why I’m not looking for a life without characters. I can notice myself playing one and still enjoy it, sustain a form for years, or stop recognizing myself in something that once felt deeply mine. The freedom I’m looking for doesn’t require me to take commitment less seriously or treat every decision to stay with suspicion. What matters to me is that no form should acquire the right to become who I am once and for all. That I can inhabit it without having to defend it against everything that happens.

And when a reality is already in front of me, I don’t have to finish explaining myself before I can face it. I can recognize that I stopped listening during a conversation and still not know why I shut down. Perhaps something familiar got the better of me. Perhaps I can see that I was defending an idea of myself. Perhaps I don’t even have the words to describe what happened. But the other person is there, and there’s something in what they were saying that I didn’t take in. I can begin listening again without having finished understanding my reaction. What I can do now doesn’t have to wait until I’ve found a satisfactory interpretation of everything that played a part in my absence.

Taking responsibility for my part doesn’t mean attributing everything that happened to myself. I can be faced with a reality I didn’t choose, one brought about by someone else. If someone decides they no longer want to continue a relationship with me, I may want to understand, ask questions, piece together a history that makes their decision understandable. But I can also spend a long time trying to explain why they’re leaving while avoiding what it means to live through their leaving. Understanding their reasons doesn’t make their decision mine, nor does it allow me to live it on their behalf. Their part remains theirs. The life I continue living in the face of it is mine.

That doesn’t mean I know what to do. I can recognize reality and remain confused. I may need to talk, learn more about the circumstances, think about the possibilities available to me. Facing something doesn’t make every choice obvious. Uncertainty is here too. Not yet knowing what I want to do can be part of being present, not necessarily a way of abandoning the moment.

Nor do I have to finish getting to know myself before I can answer for my part. If recognizing a choice as mine required me to have seen everything that went into it, something would always be missing. Later, I may discover an identification I hadn’t noticed, a loyalty I was maintaining, or a way in which I was going against myself that I couldn’t see at the time. That discovery may change how I understand what I did and what I want to do now. But it doesn’t automatically put the past on trial before the present, nor does it prove that I could have seen back then what I’m only able to recognize today.

Writing these pages is part of that movement too. I’m finding ways to express something I recognize, and those ways can help me keep thinking. But they could also become a description of myself that I feel obliged to live up to tomorrow. I could defend “I don’t betray myself,” “I don’t identify with any fixed image,” or “I’m present” precisely when something happening in my life is calling those statements into question. This essay doesn’t become immune to that risk simply by talking about it. It has to remain a formulation born of this journey, rather than becoming the version of myself I must play from now on.

The next conversation isn’t contained in what I’ve already written about my conversations. I’ll arrive carrying what I’ve lived, things I know, ways of understanding myself that may help me see. Something may surprise me, something may get the better of me again, something may become visible in a way I can’t anticipate today. I don’t need to arrive empty or forget what I’ve learned.

If I didn’t listen, I can acknowledge it without settling the question of who I am. If I still don’t understand what happened to me, I can remain with it.

An explanation can accompany me; what I construct to understand my life cannot do the living for me.